Skip to main content

Commentary 5: Fiction and emotion

PHIL 150, Introduction to philosophy, Fall 2026

1 Assignment

Begin by outlining an objection or alternative to a position in Radford or Walton. Then explain the strongest-possible response the author might give to that objection or alternative. Say whether you think the response succeeds. If necessary, describe what would have to be true in order for the author’s reply to ‘go through’.

For general guidelines, see the page on unit commentaries.